Geek to Geek Reviews

We use a scale of 1 to 5 to grade media. We consider a 1 to be a terrible experience all the way around, while 5 would be something we think everyone should experience.

We try to dive into all aspects of the games in an easy-to-digest format, while providing well-rounded and detailed discussion. Not all reviews can be broken down rigidly, but regardless of format, the grading scale and criteria remain the same.

Join our Discord to share your thoughts on games with us!

Newest Reviews

D&D 5e Heroes of the Borderlands Starter Set (Review)

by BJ Keeton

“Heroes of the Borderlands” starter set is probably the best introduction Wizards of the Coast has ever provided for D&D fifth edition, and that’s saying a lot.

Kaiju Big Battel: Fighto Fantasy – Love Letters within Love Letters

by Aaron Peterson

Kaiju Big Battel: Fighto Fantasy is the Blue Mage of monster-wrestling turn-based RPGs, using the best of its inspirations to build its own rockin’ identity.

Review: Date Everything in ‘Date Everything,’ the Dating Game Where You Can Date Everything!

by Troy Dunham

Nothing says “Happy Pride” like getting talked off by a strange, submissive man in your Air Conditioning vents whose only pleasure in life is pleasuring you.

Nautical TTRPG I Actually Like: Songs of the Spellbound Sea for DnD 5e (Review)

by BJ Keeton

I don’t generally like pirate or nautical content. Songs of the Spellbound Sea for DnD 5e has made me reconsider that statement. It has everything I could want.

The Pathfinder 2e NPC Core is the Bestiary of my Dreams

by BJ Keeton

The NPC Core for Pathfinder 2e is surprisingly versatile as a bestiary as well as a quick-and-easy way to populate your world.

Star Overdrive is Great (When You Go Fast)

by Troy Dunham

Star Overdrive promises an exciting adventure on a jet-powered hoverboard. It’s a simple pitch, but after playing a few hours of the game, it feels a bit rough.

Starfinder Galaxy Guide is a Great Bridge from First to Second Edition

by BJ Keeton

The first Starfinder 2nd Edition release isn’t a rulebook, but is filled with lore and amazing player options that complement the free playtest rules perfectly.

Starfinder 2e Playtest: ‘A Cosmic Birthday’ Ch. 1 (Review & Changes)

by BJ Keeton

The first playtest adventure for the Starfinder 2e playtest is incredibly fun, and here are the tweaks I made to the first chapter to make it even more so.

D&D 5e Monster Manual (2024) Review

by BJ Keeton

The new Monster Manual is a gorgeous book with gorgeous art and a mix of hits and a few misses inside.

Afterlove EP Review – From the Heart

by Aaron Peterson

Afterlove EP is rough and raw but thematically rich and clear in its vision – about love, perhaps, but of all colors of relationships, of community, and of art itself.