Mayhem in Single Valley Cover Image

Mayhem in Single Valley (Steam) First Impressions: The New Scott Pilgrim?

Quick View

Release Date: May 20, 2021
Price: $14.99
Rating: Everyone
Platform: Steam, Epic Games, GOG
A game key for Mayhem in Single Valley was provided by tinyBuild.

What a fun ride! I want to hurry and finish the review so I can play more! Mayhem in Single Valley is a polished, sharp, fun little adventure game that hits ya like a catchy 80s pop song; you can’t get it out of your head! Moreover, it has the feel of Scott Pilgrim in the epicness you feel doing something as mundane as picking up dog poop.

The Story

Jack Johnson (no relation) is about to fly to the city to attend art school–a wonderful opportunity and chance to escape the dead-end lifestyle of his not-so-well-to-do family. All that remains is a couple of chores and…what’s this? Mysterious shadow entities dumping toxic waste into the town’s water supply? Oh, dear! Well, what’s a helpful/mischievous lad in a red-hooded sweatshirt supposed to do but grab some trashcan lids and fight mutant forest animals!?

Screenshot from mayhem in single valley - mayhem in single valley (steam) first impressions: the new scott pilgrim?

If the plot seems cheesy or borrowed from like, I dunno, 40% of the 8-bit platformers in the 80s, it’s only because it’s on purpose. Nostalgia abounds. But Mayhem in Single Valley is much more than homage. With such tight controls, character handling and fluid animations, there’s an earnestness and commitment belying the game’s simple plot.

Action! Adventure!

Plus, it’s NOT a platformer. Straight-up action-adventure game in 3D! Almost. The incredible lighting and water effects are fabulous. The gorgeous character sprites (pixelated but not really sprites) are 2D but the semi-voxel environment is 3D. All action takes place in 3D. Like a charming cross between Paper Mario and Zelda: A Link to the Past.

Screenshot from mayhem in single valley - mayhem in single valley (steam) first impressions: the new scott pilgrim?

The combat, however, is definitely neither of those. No master sword or hammers here. You get a slingshot and…acorns. Maybe a bug or dead fish. There are unique and interesting ways to dispose of the afflicted, glowing green-eyed vermin that assail you, but stabby-stab isn’t one of them. It’s not quite as pacifist-y as, say, Undertale but fun to figure out!

The physics are great and make the puzzles loads of fun to solve. Dying is hilarious. The pacing is brisk and relentless, making it hard to get up and walk away. Plus, you can pet the dog.

Petting the dog in mayhem in single valley - mayhem in single valley (steam) first impressions: the new scott pilgrim?


  • Fast paced and easy to pick up
  • Has a lot of heart
  • Has a lot of humor
  • Brilliant graphical style
  • One of the best soundtracks ever


  • Couldn’t find all my clones
  • Square duct tape

Carrie Lambertsen

Carrie Lambertsen

Elinzia sews, she crafts, she crochets, and she plays a LOT of video games. She is the co-host of The Nerdberg Review podcast, host of My HGTV Addiction podcast, and runs the Etsy store, TheCraftingRogue. You can also find her RPG musings on


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

%d bloggers like this: